The racial divide in this country is deeper than even Gabby Douglas can surmount (Gabby Douglas’s Hair Foibles at London Olympics: Editor’s Notebook, Aug. 8, 2012).
Controversy about the Olympic gold medalist spread faster than a pandemic this week after negative Tweets surfaced about her ponytail and hair texture on Twitter. The ruckus has provoked lingering conversations about race.
Some people seem to think that race should be completely stripped from conversations about Douglas, who is the first African-American gymnast to win a gold medal in the all-around. She’s an American hero, they say. Leave her race out of it. But, race isn’t something Douglas can take off and on like her medals.
“When you’re ‘America’s Sweetheart’ like Douglas, the topic of race is to be swept back in a ponytail. But when you are President Barack Obama, race is inextricable.”
The ugly truth is that calling attention to being an African-American in this country gets the most play when the rhetoric is decidedly negative and is about crime, welfare or politics. When you’re “America’s Sweetheart “like Douglas, the topic of race is to be swept back in a ponytail. But when you are President Barack Obama, race is inextricable.
Gabby Douglas is an inspiration to all Americans, but especially to the young African-American girls who now see her accomplishment as a possibility for themselves. That is why African-Americans herald Douglas’s victory.
The troubling question is: Why does that seem to bother so many people?
– Dana L. Boone, Des Moines, IA
Tom
10:10 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012
I am tired of the African American term all together. We are black or white I don't hear anyone saying they are Polish/American or Russian/American etc. We have now reached a point of reverse discriminination and enough is enough.
Dana Boone
12:31 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012
We define ourselves on our own terms. We give respect to our history by saying African-American. How is what I view myself as discriminating against anyone?
MaskedBlogger
3:54 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
I'd need a giant box on an application for mine. Let's see, I'm an English, Irish, Scottish, Welsh, French, Dutch, Native American/American.
Lori Y
2:22 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012
Funny that "the majority" that has discrminated against us for so long now finds it offensive that we call ourselves African-Americans. Don't they remember -- they stole us away from Africa and enslaved us. And actually, it is widely accepted that Africa is actually the birthplace of civilization. Hell, if you go back far enough to Paradise, we're all African-Americans!
Kurt B.
8:12 am on Friday, August 10, 2012
I am not sure this is the way it happened. If you read up on the history of the way it all supposedly happened ( since none of us were around to witness this ), the people that were sold into the trade were gathered up by their fellow countrymen. I don't think any of us are proud of this occuring, but none of us had anything to do with it, so why are we still blaming things of over 400 years ago on the current population ? Let's start working on the issues facing this nation right now : continuing unemployment, a debt crisis that will eventually change the entire world ( been reading up on whats going on in Europe, anyone ? ), overtaxation, etc etc
Dana Boone
3:07 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012
Great points, Lori. It's amazing that in 2012 some think they have the power and right to rename us.
MaskedBlogger
3:56 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
Excuse me, the name has been changed many times just since 1960.
Erik Gable
4:19 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012
I'm not sure how the first poster has managed to not hear anyone calling themselves Polish-American, German-American and so on, because I've heard it plenty of times. It's just that nobody freaks out about it. (Must like the way an Irish flag on St. Patrick's Day is just fine, but a Mexican flag on Cinco de Mayo can trigger a full-scale meltdown in some people.)
Curiously, it seems like the same folks who gripe about "political correctness" if a nonwhite criminal defendant isn't identified by race will be among the FIRST to gripe if you mention the race of an accomplished person such as an Olympic gymnast. Which I believe was the writer's point.
Troy Murphy
12:25 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
Erik the controversy about cinco de mayo had nothing to do with mexican flag and everything to do with the fact kids wearing American flags were ordered to take them off and sent home.
I have also not heard any other group consistently and as vociferously describe themselves as hyphenated Americans. You hear it on occasion.
I have also not heard anyone complain about how criminals are identified, usually they are just referred to as criminals unless they are trying to catch said person in which case race is usually identified to help in the apprehension whether that be white, black, asian, hispanic, etc.
MaskedBlogger
4:00 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
The meltdown is caused by the fact that yes, we all came from different places, but our ancestors did it LEGALLY. That flag on Cinco De Mayo triggers anger at the fact that our borders aren't secure and ILLEGAL people are coming here, using our facilities and not paying their fair share. Want me to talk about going the supermarket, standing behind a family watching them use their card to purchase food and then going out and getting into a brand new 30,000. truck? When you don't pay taxes and you make nothing on paper and you get welfare and food stamps, you get to own nice things. The rest of us struggle to make our payments. I live in a state with one of those borders....so I know what I'm talking about.
Troy Murphy
7:30 am on Friday, August 10, 2012
Lori,
You might want to check your history, I believe 90 percent of the of the people sold out of Africa were enslaved by fellow Africans and sold by Africans to European slave traders who in turn transshipped through the carribean and brought them here where they were sold again.
MaskedBlogger
4:01 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
Exactly, but that seems to be a point that is almost always ignored.
MaskedBlogger
4:04 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
Seriously, Gabby is a member of a TEAM representing the USA, not African-Americans. She's an American representing her country at the Olympics. Why does race ALWAYS have to come into play. It's like you want to keep the division. Why can't it be that she's just that good, she won the gold. She's a fantastic athlete, forget her race, just credit her talent and dedication.
Dana Boone
8:47 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
Race comes into play because in 2012 some people still have a big problem with the term African-American. If you're not black, I'm not sure why you care. Race is an issue because when you're black and a hero, suddenly race doesn't matter. But, every other day of the year, it does.
And, regardless of who sold whom into slavery, this country enslaved blacks for centuries and did unspeakable horrors to them, but hey, I guess that might be a source of pride for some, instead of the incredible shame it actually is.
Regardless, I'm proud of Gabby. She's a shining African-American hero.
Troy Murphy
11:26 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
BTW this country didn't enslave blacks, people enslaved blacks, blacks enslaved blacks as well as whites enslaving blacks. I may be wrong but I don't remember it ever being US Government policy to use slaves or to own slaves. You also fail to notice that free blacks also owned slaves in the US in numbers disproportionate to southern whites. But you never hear of the incredible shame of blacks owning black slaves. Look up William Ellison from North Carolina Born in 1790 as a slave named April who lived to be 71 and at 26 was freed by his owner. In 1860 he was the largest black owner of slaves in NC. One of the largest sources of his income came from breeding slaves. A practice that was generally looked upon with disgust in the south.
Troy Murphy
10:59 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012
I am not black and I really don't care what you label youself. The point I am trying to make is that as long as you see yourself in terms of your race and not as just an American others will also see you in those terms. It would be like me writing this blog or every time someone spoke about me they said Troy the european-american, it would set me apart as different from other Americans. It is you who insists on labeling yourself and others. Maybe Gabby would prefer to be known as the talented girl who won a gold at the Olympics. Maybe for her race isn't an issue. I don't remember Michelle Kwan being labeled by anyone as a Chinese-American who won silver and bronze just as a talented American figure skater. Possibly As early as 2040 whites are projected to be the minority in the US. At that point who knows maybe I will feel differently.
Dana Boone
12:08 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012
The point I'm trying to make is that African-Americans shouldn't be asked to deny pride in the fact that Gabby helped break down racial barriers in the field of gymnastics - or change how we describe ourseves (with that pesky little hyphen) to make anyone feel better.
Dana Boone
12:22 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012
This country had policies and laws in place to keep blacks enslaved, but you already know that. It sounds like you are trying to justify slavery and over-emphasize that some blacks were complicit in it - as if that is going to obscure the fact that you are so very bothered by the term African-American and black pride and our refusal to acquiese to mainstream preferences.
Troy Murphy
1:20 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012
Boy that is a stretch. Justify slavery? Really? No the point I am trying to make is that you were never a slave and I have never enslaved anyone. That is history and really is not relevant to modern America, if it was relevant we would not have a black president. If you want to continue to identify yourself as African-American I really could care less, I just think it is unfair of you to label others. It would never occur to me to label someone competing in the Olympics an Asian-American or a hispanic-American European-American or for that matter an African-American. What bothers me is that you want to define everyone with your skin color by a moniker they may not ascribe too or want. I know how divided whites are as a group and find it hard to believe that universally all blacks in the U.S. consider themselves african-Americans, they might agree they are black, but I even doubt that. What are you if your dad is African-American and your mom is European-American? Or if your dad is African-American and your mom is Asian-American? I happen to like golf and I don't recall Tiger being described by either moniker but only as one great golfer. I don't know if he was the first great black golfer, it never ocurred to me to ask, I just know he is an exceptional golfer. My point still stands if you want to self-identify as african-american then expect others to see you as african-american rather than just an american.
Troy Murphy
1:55 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012
Btw what is Tiger Woods? An African-American or an Asian-American. My guess is he is whatever HE wants to be, hopefully that is "just" an American
Dana Boone
5:54 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012
Thanks for finally getting my point. We are what we want to be, not what anyone else prefers.
Troy Murphy
11:33 pm on Sunday, August 12, 2012
Really, that's why you labeled Douglas the first African-American gymnast to win a gold medal because that was what she wanted to be labeled.